Skip to content

Are Lee Hsien Loong and Ho Ching as Corrupt as Najib and Rosmah?


“Corruption: a form of dishonesty undertaken by a person entrusted with a position of authority often to acquire personal benefit”

In the last couple of days the world has been drawn to the spectacle of Malaysia’s ex-PM, Najib Razak, being arrested and, after spending a night in detention being charged in court with corruption and criminal breach of trust. This stunning reversal of fortune was almost unimaginable two months ago and has given new hope to those who believe in democracy everywhere but particularly in South East Asia. With a stroke Malaysia has leapt far ahead of Singapore in the good governance stakes and Singaporeans, long accustomed and conditioned by their government to regard Malaysia as a Latin American/Muslim banana republic on their doorstep, can no longer feel smug in their own country’s superiority.

The amount of MYR 42 million covered by the charges may be relatively small compared to the total US$4.5 billion that Najib and his accomplices are alleged to have siphoned off from 1MDB but it is only the tip of the iceberg and more charges will surely follow. If they do then awkward questions will follow for Singapore given that Sarawak Report estimates RM 100 billion is banked overseas.

I had the good fortune to attend a dinner in London last Saturday to celebrate the victory of the Opposition Pakatan Harapan (or Party of Hope) coalition, attended by Anwar Ibrahim’s daughter, MP and PKR Vice President, Nurul Izzah. I also attended subsequent public and private events in the  same week where Malaysian civil society activists spoke. Foremost among these was the Malaysian cartoonist, Zunar, whose fearless pillorying of Rosmah’s penchant for jewellery and Birkin handbags costing millions of dollars became legendary.  For exposing the corruption and greed of those in power Zunar was charged with sedition (which the PAP also finds a useful colonial-era law that can be used to crush dissent and was successfully used to cow the Singaporean cartoonist Leslie Chew into submission). Had the Opposition not won the election Zunar was looking at a potential jail sentence of 43 years!

Cartoonkini-ROSMAH-WEAR-18-May-2017-1024x808 (1)

Also speaking at that dinner was Clare Rewcastle-Brown  the sister in law of former UK PM Gordon Brown. Clare is an intrepid investigative reporter (do we even have one such journalist  in Singapore?) instrumental in exposing  the fraud and theft going on at 1MDB through her online “Sarawak Report.” At one point she was subject to an NTB ( no travel ban) but this has now been lifted and she was welcomed as a returning hero by Malaysians.

At The Free Word Centre I also heard and met David Diaz-Jogeix and Nalini Elumalai from Article 19 (which campaigns for freedom of expression and a free media) and Shamini Darshni Kalimuthu from Amnesty International. Some of you may remember The Free Word Centre as a place I took Roy Ngerng to visit.

What struck me most about the Malaysian activists, particularly Zunar, was that they were not treating the Opposition victory as Mission Accomplished. Zunar pointed out how the Malaysian media had turned overnight from supporting Najib to vying with each other to support the new regime. Zunar would like to see the media holding the new Government to account and demonstrating independence.  Quite rightly he sees the necessity of entrenching checks and balances and reforming institutions to make sure that the new Government cannot just step into the authoritarian shoes of the BN and UMNO and continue in the old repressive ways. The Malaysian activists are impressive in how they see the necessity of making the Government accountable

The reforms that he and the other activists want to see introduced are those advocated by the Reformasi movement and are very familiar to anyone who saw or viewed online  my  late father JBJ speaking at the launch of the Reform Party here in Singapore.  Reformasi has been 30 years in the making so it is no wonder that JBJ was synched with their aims. These aims include abolishing the Printing Presses Act (which is not as draconian as the Singaporean version, the Sedition Act, the Internal Security Act, repealing the recently passed Anti-Fake News Act (which Singapore would have likely followed if Najib had retained power) reforming the Official Secrets Act and introducing a Freedom of Information Act which would protect whistleblowers, checking the powers of the police through setting up independent watchdogs, ensuring an independent judiciary and taking the MACC, Electoral  Commission and Human Rights Commission out of the Prime Minister’s Office and placing them under Parliamentary control.

It is worth noting that Zunar and Clare can now travel freely and return to Malaysia whilst our satirical cartoonists and dissidents continue to be banned from their homeland for life.

Given the closeness of Singapore’s and Malaysia’s political and legal systems, all the reforms of laws and institutions advocated in Malaysia apply with equal or greater force to Singapore. My father often spoke of how total reform of the system was required and not just some tweaks and adjustments. Malaysians are set on achieving that albeit in steps.

Singaporeans have long regarded Malaysia as corrupt, chaotic and practising egregious discrimination against its talented and hardworking minorities (while forgetting of course the discrimination the majority race practises against minorities in Singapore. However if the new Malaysian Government keeps to its promises of Reformasi then Malaysia should leapfrog Singapore in the Good Governance stakes.

But can Singapore still hold onto its crown of having a corruption free government (which has always been more of a studiously cultivated illusion than a reality)? Let’s examine our first family, our version of Najib and Rosmah.

The public face is that our First Lady makes a big show of her handbags. But no vintage Birkin for her! She carries an artisan crafted  handbag with a market value of  S$14 whilst she often dresses as though her clothes have been made from the living room curtains. PM Lee’s sister goes one further and seems to actually wear the home furnishings when forced to change out of sports shorts. Does this ostentatious show of lack of ostentation therefore indicate lack of corruption?  Not really. The trainer clad Weiling lives in a condominium corruptly purchased by the Lee family (I should point out here that after shareholders complained they later returned the discounts and claimed not to have known they were getting a special deal on the condominiums not available to the public.) So, more a case of vintage Hermes Birkin clothed in my father’s batik.

ho ching $14 bag

Then there is the abuse of power that was the direction of all HDB’s conveyancing business, and presumably a lot of other Government legal work,  by LKY to his wife’s (and his) law firm (Lee & Lee) going back to the 1960s. For those of you not familiar with HDB you should be aware that up to 90% of or population lives in a Housing Development Board unit that is purchased on a long lease from the government.

How about PM Lee? Does he abuse his power for personal benefit? I think we can answer categorically, yes! He sued Roy Ngerng in his  personal capacity whilst a serving PM. He used his Press Secretary to defend his personal law suit to the world’s leaders and media. Throughout the trial the lawyers frequently slipped and referred to the plaintiff as  the PM. The PM is also Chairman of GIC and has appointed his wife as CEO and ED of Temasek. The PM has given his son a job in the Government Technology Agency which comes under the Prime Minister’s Office. Historically all his family have had high positions and control of key industries and departments. Even in what passes for the “private” sector in Singapore they still pick up directorships and sinecures with ease.

Whilst there are allegations that Najib’s stepson benefitted from 1MDB money to set up the production company that made Wolf of Wall Street neither he nor Mahathir appointed their own sons and wives to government positions or State Industries. Anwar Ibrahim’s wife and daughter are MPs but they were democratically elected whilst in opposition, are accountable to the people and can be removed at the next poll. In Singapore we can try asking how much Ho Ching gets paid but we will not get an answer. Indeed Tharman arrogantly said in Parliament that it was not in the national interest for Singaporeans to know how much she is paid (illustrating how Singaporeans are wrong to place their faith for reform in Tharman).

Also Lee Hongyi, the Prime Minister’s son worked for Google for two years. While this might have been a secondment from the Civil Service (to give him a grounding in harvesting citizens’ data and snooping?) it probably should be investigated by the US Justice Dept under the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, just as many Asian hires by US banks have been. Both J P Morgan and Credit Suisse have paid substantial fines for giving jobs to Chinese “princelings” because their parents controlled state firms that could direct business to those banks. Presumably Singapore has given substantial business to Google (or its parent company Alphabet)?

There is also the appointment of PM Lee’s personal lawyer, Lucien Wong, as AG.

Appointing family members and friends falls under the definition of abuse of power for personal benefit and therefore corruption in the wider meaning of the term.  In this regard the Malaysian former First Family is less “corrupt” than ours. However the Lees would just say that family appointments are based on merit going back to the 1980s when Government sycophants were wheeled out to say that LHL’s glittering career should not be held back because of who his father was.

How about hard cash going into private Bank accounts? There is no evidence of this. Then again there is no evidence as to where most our state money is and crucially even how much money there is. If we try to ask we are told it’s a national secret or that it would take too many man hours to calculate.

The stark facts is that we Singaporeans would not know if there was any corruption. We simply do not have the mechanism for discovering it and this is one of the reasons that Malaysian activists are hard on the heels of the new government to put those mechanism in place.  We certainly have not seen any whistleblowing from those who could, Chip Goodyear, Tan Jee Say, Weiling, Hsien Yang and his kids.

I have done my best. I attended the CPF forum run by a government minister Hri Kumar but as we all know he dodged my questions about holes in the accounting and then tried to employ smear tactics. I was also at that forum forced to defend an elderly lady who was doxxed by her own MP and became the victim of hate crimes as a result.

Again I personally took the government to court over the IMF loan after every effort to get the President and the MOF to show some accountability failed. The appeal was partially crowd funded by you, the good citizens of Singapore but even with that show of public interest we got no answers as I was declared to have no Locus Standi. However there was a blind panic in the President’s office after this and the Auditor General finally did a small part of the job he was paid for and found another illegal loan which the Government then had to repay. If I did not scrutinise what passes for Government Accounts these illegal loans would go unnoticed.

When M Ravi took Madam Vellama’s case to court to put a check on the PM’s previously unfettered power I again interceded when a Law Society official tried to get him barred mid-case.

There is a limit to what I can do in my personal capacity. We simply do we have the checks and balances that could prevent the type of fraud that was perpetrated in Malaysia with 1MDB and other projects that are only just coming to light, from happening in Singapore. We do know that the Government over the past fifty years has amassed a much greater control over the nation’s resources. As I have pointed out for years, we have no clue as to what assets the Government owns or their value. The sums as compared to 1MDB are infinitely larger. At the top of this pyramid sits the Lee family.

There are several reasons that the fraud in Malaysia came to light whereas information on our state finances is locked tight. The CPIB, like the MACC, comes under the control of the PM. But Najib was only an adviser to 1MDB and one reason the fraud came to light was that Najib had to use outside individuals and companies to perpetrate it. He did not have the level of control of every business and Industry that the Lee dynasty exerts.

Then there  were whistleblowers who passed information to the Wall Street Journal and the Sarawak Report and some fearless journalists. No journalist in Singapore would ever investigate anything unless she was given the green light to do so by those in power.

In addition Najib had a weak spot in Jho Low who blew the money openly and flamboyantly. He gave jewellery to the model Miranda Kerr worth $9million to be linked romantically with him and paid  Leonardo DiCaprio US$500,000 just to get on a flight with him. The whole Hollywood connection ensured that the 1MDB scandal became big news globally. Jho Low has been tracked down to Maccau and at this moment it is thought that he is seeking asylum from extradition.

wolf of wall street

 

In Singapore control by the ruling family is absolute.

Najib and PM Lee were always very friendly unlike the frequent clashes between his father and Mahathir but obviously the Lee dynasty and the PAP have a vested interest in the Malaysian Opposition failing and seeing the devil they know returned to power.  If the Malaysian opposition succeeds – and it is early days yet as Parliament has not even convened- then the pressure on Singapore to finally reform will be insurmountable.

Finally, how to answer the question in the title?  Honestly, I haven’t got a clue. This will not change till Singaporeans take ownership of their destinies and start demanding some accountability and control over the assets that should belong to them but that the Lee family keep so tightly within their grasp. More than one-third of the seats in Parliament would be a start.

Links

https://kenjeyaretnam.com/2012/07/03/you-ask-me-i-ask-who/

https://kenjeyaretnam.com/2018/02/20/budget-2018-same-old-cliches-as-heng-makes-your-money-vanish-in-the-uniquely-singaporean-version-of-the-shell-game/

https://kenjeyaretnam.com/2018/04/12/while-norway-insists-on-transparency-our-familee-managed-swfs-prefer-the-fishing-in-muddy-waters/

https://kenjeyaretnam.com/2014/06/15/8-dishonest-things-about-hri-kumars-honest-conversation/

 

 

10 Comments »

  1. Can you do more besides being a blogger,a keyboard warrior? Your dad was greatly admired for his “grassroots footworks” and in my opinion, a people’s champion among the constituents and has left a great legacy as a fearless warrior for the people, which I hope you will continue to uphold. Please do more
    ( you are really doing a good job but can you do even better? ) because you have the inherited intellectual and hopefully the ”guts” of your Dad. Unlike you dad who was forced to sell the Party’s newspaper on street corners to raise fund for the party and maybe to put bread on the table for you and your siblings, I guess you are finanacially well endowed to do better. You are a silver of hope for change and awareness that there can better tomorrow for many of us common Singgies folks, if we made to know that there are many other alternatives to the present oppressive system and governance.

    Like

  2. Martin Wolf on FT 18 July:

    ” The poor state of so many Americans is in part the product of plutocratic politics: a relentless and systematic devotion to the interests of the very rich. As I have argued before, a politics of low taxes, low social spending and high inequality is sustainable in a universal suffrage democracy only with a mixture of propaganda in favour of “trickle down” economics, splitting the less well off on cultural and racial lines, ruthless gerrymandering and outright voter suppression. All this has indeed happened”.

    Spot on! Could he have been talking also about Singapore?

    Like

  3. “Whilst there are allegations that Najib’s stepson benefitted from 1MDB money to set up the production company that made Wolf of Wall Street neither he nor Mahathir appointed their own sons and wives to government positions or State Industries.”

    I believe neither Najib or for that matter Mahathir could transform UMNO into a family dynasty like LKY could with the PA and the chinese majority. Najib never enjoyed the 2/3 majority and any attempt by either men to place their sons or wives in power would have resulted in public protest and riot if not a revolt within UNMO.

    PAP is LKY and vice versa. The power and control by the Lee family is ansolute. Therefore he was able to put his son as PM with a seat warmer in the interim, GCT whilst holding on to power. As JBJ used to joke, “Goh is the PM in the SM office”.

    Likewise the current 4G pick are a bunch of sycophants, apple polishers or brown nosers. Neither will dare defy the Lees in even a small measure.

    It is likely one will be picked to be a regeant while LHL maintains full control as SM with Hongyi biding his time.

    Elections here are a farce. I am surprised neither the RP or SDP seem to realise this after all these years.

    Like

  4. “More than one-third of the seats in Parliament would be a start.”

    I am not optimistic this will happen in Singapore. Unlike Malaysia we have regressed politically. Harapan’s victory at the polls was a culmination of 30 years of active citizenry. We do not have that in Singapore.

    Najib can’t even get kangkung past M’sians without ridicule and mass protest.

    In Singapore the PAP can steal the Presidential elections from the Chinese majority without a squeak of protest. Imagine the hurdles they will put before the GE.

    Snap! Like Thanos and in 4 days elections are over with 90% seats to PAP with the rest going to faux opposition, WP.

    Like

    • No sir. LKY in a twisted way is right. Singapore as we know today a capitalist economy with a repressive regime and cruel austerity will not have happened without the Chinese majority. You can strip the rights from the Chinese completely and they will not even realise it.

      Look no further than China. Xi Jinping is now president for life. The 1.2 billion Chinese have no problems with it. They have forgotten the term limits were put in place by the communist party themselves after Mao earned the distinction of being the biggest mass murderer ever. More kills than Hitler, Tojo, Stalin, Leopold, Pol Pot, Caesar, Amin and Genghis Khan combined.

      Until the day the demographics changes, the Chinese have the lowest TFE after all and we stop importing mainland Chinese to make up the numbers, the PAP or another family will be Singapore’s imperial dynasty.

      Like

      • Your comments are undermined by the fact that both Taiwan and Malaysia have achieved democracy though admittedly the Chinese are only 30% of the population. Also the brave struggles of Hong Kongers and willingness to go to jail for democracy show that it’s not true. It’s just another outmoded racist heory that LKY shared with James Watson who discovered DNA

        Like

  5. Definitely, they are corrupted. You have left out other notables like Kwa Chong Seng, Lee Hsien Loong’s cousin from the mother’s side. He was Deputy Chairman of Temasek at the same time as Loong’s wife Ho Ching. Imagine wife and cousin on the top of Temasek.They could be stealing the place blind and no one would know. Also Ho Ching’s sister Ho Pheng who was grinding away as a lowly Principal of a 3rd rate school before being catapulted to the upper echelons of MOE upon Ho Ching’s marriage to Loong. Also, have u ever wonder why the teflon man Wong Kan Seng was immune from any punishment for incompetences such as the escape of Mas Selamat? Well, it turns out he is married to Ruth Lee Hong Geok, the niece of Lee KUan Yew. Many more such conflicts and corruption. BTW, if Hsien Yang had not revealed it, who in SIngapore would know that Loong pocketed a cool $20 million from selling his share in Oxley to his brother. Such income must be declared.

    Like

  6. interesting Reading. I am also eager to know the salary paid to the Managing Director of Temasek /GIC as long as they are paid from public money. All monies paid by the nation should be transparent. Citizens have the right to know of such information. I really cant understand the logic for not disclosing the emoluments of such officers. The press has revealed the salaries paid to the CEOs of our Banks. Why not Temasek and GIC CEOs? Such information should be institutionalised so that successive governments will also comply. I am all for responsibility, accountability and integrity.

    Like

    • Singapore Government, LHL, his corrupt wife, son and relatives now in the PAP or States Organisation are all CORRUPT. A transparent government would not employ relatives connected to the Lees or otherwise into any organisation. There should not be any reasons to, because there are more highly intelligent and qualified people to hold such positions.

      When you employ relatives, nominated by LHL or his croonies, Singaporeans are not allowed to challenge them. The only member I can recalled I would say is not corrupt is LHY.
      He would rather step down or go into excile! Why? Because he or his family would not want to be dragged into the bad name of the FAMILEES! Hence he left Singapore so that his reputation would not be tainted! What a Gentleman. Even his son stand up and be counted.

      I know typical Singaporeans! They would moaned! Cry Wolf unlike Malaysians. Time Singaporeans, stand TALL and be like their Malaysians Brothers! VOTE THEM OUT AND DONT JUST TALK!!!!!! DO IT!!!!! OPPOSITIONS PLEASE STAND UNITED AGAINST THE PAP AND GET RID OF THEM!!! BE LIKE MAHATHIR ANWAR AND THE REST OF OPPOSTIONS. UNITE TOGETHER NOT AGAINST EACH OTHER AND GET RID OF PAP. GIVE TO DAYS PUBLIC HOLIDAYS AND START TO SCRUTINISE THE BOOKS, BANK ACCOUNTS OF EVERYONE WITHIN THE PAP AND LHL FAMILY. BARRED THEM FROM TRAVEL CONFISCATE THEIR PASSPORT AND PUT THEM ON HOUSE ARREST. DIG DEEP FOR CORRUPT PRACTISE, LOSS OF STATE INVESTMENTS, QUESTIONS WHY THE ARE ENTITLED TO BONUS OR HIGH SALARIES WHEN THE LOSS TO THE STATE CORPORATIONS OR CPF FUNDS ARE SO HIGH! THEY SHOULD BE ASKED TO PAY THEM BACK. SO FREEZE THEIR ASSETS, ACCOUNTS INCLUDING THEIR ACCOUNTS IN THE SWISS BANKS ETC. DO IT QUICK NOT TALK AND MOANED BEFORE THEY RUN AWAY. CONFISCATED THEIR PASSPORT AND BARRED LHL, HIS FAMILY AND CROONIES FROM TRAVEL LIKE MAHATHIR TO NAJIB. PUT THEM ALL UNDER ARREST AND TAKE THE NECESSARY STEPS TO INSTITUTE ALL THE CRIMINAL CHARGES AVAILABLE TO PUT THEM BEHIND BAR!! SEIZE THEIR ASSETS!!!!! DO IT QUICK!!!! BEFORE THE MOVE THE UNDS ABROAD!!!! EVEN AG LAW MINISTERS ETC WAS SUMMONED TO MALAYSIA TO EXPLAIN TO MAHATHIR SO SOMETHING IS GOING ON LHL, SUBRAMANIAM, MAS ETC ARE AWARE THEIR PART IN NAJIB CASE! AND THAT OF TEMARSIK GIC ETC. NO ONE WAS ABLE TO CHALLENGE BECAUSE THERE ARE NO OUTRIGHT OPPOSITION TO KICK THEM OUT! NOW IS THE TIME TO ACT AND FOLLOW YOUR MALAYSIAN BROTHERS!!! VOTE THEM OUT, CONFISCATE THEIR PASSPORT AND BAR THEM FROM TRAVEL. IF IT TAKE 6 MONTHS OR A YEAR TO DIG OUT ALL THE WORMS, DO IT!!! VOTE THEM OUT

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: